Rumor check: Brad Brach
Brach, 31, has a 2.75 ERA in 39 appearances for the Orioles this season. He is 15 for 19 in save opportunities since assuming closing duties after the injury to Zach Britton in April.
Over the previous two seasons as a setup reliever for the Orioles, Brach posted a 2.39 ERA over 133 appearances. He is making $3.05 million this year and has one final year of arbitration eligibility ahead of him before becoming a free agent at the end of the 2018 season.
It is the trade season and relief help is always highly coveted and it’s likely that teams like the Red Sox, the Nationals, and any number of other contending teams have already checked in on Brach. And as history has shown us, are likely willing to go further for him than the Cardinals are.
The Cardinals most desperate immediate need is someone who could come in and step into the closer’s role in St. Louis to solidify the bullpen. Brach would provide that answer both this year and next for a team in need of one.
USA Today suggests that the Cardinals could acquire Brach for left handed pitcher Tyler Lyons who would go immediately into their MLB-worst starting rotation. That would be really selling low on Brach, in my opinion.
The Athletics just got two of the Nationals’ top-20 prospects for a pair of relievers who make more money and haven’t been as effective as Brach over the past few years. Granted Sean Doolittle has plenty of years remaining on his contract, but I think the Orioles would want one of the Cardinals’ top-20 prospects to make the trade happen, and I’d assume a pitching prospect. Luke Weaver might be too high up the prospect list for the Cardinals to stomach parting with, but an Austin Gomber, Dakota Hudson, or Jake Woodford might fit the bill.
I’ve always been high on Lyons’ ability as a setup-type reliever, but I also wonder what the result would be if you just used Lyons in the role you’d use Brach in. Could he step into the closer’s role?