What happened. The St. Louis Cardinals promoted IF Breyvic Valera from Triple-A Memphis.
The story. With the public admission last night that Matt Carpenter‘s shoulder has bothered him all season, the Cardinals looked to add some depth to help cover potential absences from the lineup.
The numbers. Valera, 25, was signed as an international free agent back in 2010 and has now played in 800 minor league games over 8 seasons with the club. He was added to the team’s 40 man roster last winter to protect him from the Rule 5 Draft and has put together his best minor league season this year with Memphis. He has hit .314/.368/.450 with 8 home runs over 117 games with Memphis. This season he has set or tied career highs in doubles, triples, and home runs.
Valera’s best tool might be his versatility. If you include the Arizona Fall League, Valera has appeared at every position on the diamond except pitcher and catcher in his minor league career. This year he has starts at Memphis at second base, third base, left field, and right field.
The impact. 7/10. The impact is more in the admission that Carpenter has been dealing with an injury most of the season than the call up of Valera.
Carpenter told reporters after an unexplained early exit yesterday that he had been managing shoulder pain much of the season and that a recent flareup, suggested to be due to the recent decision to mix him in at third base with the absence of Jedd Gyorko, might keep him out of the lineup.
He added that the sensation is a sharp pain on pretty much every throw and on most swings. It might help explain why Carpenter has a career low .241 batting average and second-worst slugging percentage of his career. He has hit .188 since August 1st.
As I tweeted last night, for an established player to play through an injury to the potential detriment of his team is one of those selfish acts that I will never understand. If you’re fighting for a position, I get it a little more. But a guy like Carpenter is secure in his job and has a commitment from the organization.
Let’s just think about this. Rather than get the injury looked at and potentially dealt with earlier in the year, Carpenter played through it and forced the trade of Matt Adams. Since that trade, Adams has outplayed Carpenter, 117 wRC+ to 110 wRC+. Then later this season, Carpenter’s every day play forced the demotion of Luke Voit who has never gotten traction.
Also how different does this season look if Carpenter gets it treated earlier in the season and is healthy today and is the 130 wRC+ player he’s been in his career over the 100 wRC+ player he’s been since August 1? That’s why I think playing through and grinding through injuries is generally short sighted. Especially when you can’t perform up to your own personal standard while doing it.