Peavy lights up Twitter

Talk of a potential trade for Jake Peavy lit up Twitter this evening. Word is that Boston is interested in moving Peavy before tomorrow’s game to make room on the roster for prospect Rubby De La Rosa. Most of the fuel for the fire came from a post by Ken Rosenthal at FOX Sports that mentions the teams spoke a month ago and that Boston likes St. Louis’ outfield prospects. I’m thinking you’d struggle to find a team that’s not interested in any of St. Louis’ outfield prospects, but that doesn’t make for good click bait.

I’m not that interested in Peavy. He has one season of above average ERA+ over the last five years. He is currently 1-7 with a 4.64 ERA. The one benefit he’d have is that he should be able to log innings, something that the team is likely watching for both Shelby Miller and Carlos Martinez. However, his ability keep the opposing teams off the scoreboard is what’s in question these days.

Since the initial report, the Post Dispatch’s Derrick Goold indicated that the Cardinals are looking for offense, not Peavy. In a later tweet he added that John Mozeliak said that they feel trading for a top pitcher would require one of their younger starting pitchers, resulting in a net loss of years of control. That doesn’t necessarily add up to eliminate acquiring Peavy, but that any move for Peavy would include an offense upgrade as well. It probably means the Cardinals won’t be trading for David Price either (I’d be surprised if he went anywhere at this point), though, Mozeliak always plays his cards close to his chest.

The more I really look at it, the more I think the team will be fairly silent at the deadline. There is no position where this team is easily augmented. Any move to upgrade the offense would require a major change in the team as we know it. Maybe that’s good, maybe that’s bad. But dumpster diving for an underperforming player on another team doesn’t make any sense to me. We have plenty of underperforming players on our roster that don’t cost us anything to hope for improvement with.

And unless Mozeliak changes the way he’s done business, we aren’t going to pay the price to bring in a game changing player like a David Price.

Comments on this entry are closed.